The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) blocked Coles from building a new supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder in July 2026, exercising new regulatory powers [1]. Coles has appealed the decision before the Australian Competition Tribunal, with eight days of hearings concluding on Thursday in Melbourne's Federal Court [1]. The tribunal's three-member panel has reserved its decision and is required to make a determination within 90 days [1].
The case represents a significant test of Australia's new merger laws and has drawn considerable local opposition to the ACCC's decision [1]. Kalgoorlie-Boulder's former Deputy Mayor Doug Daws expressed frustration with the regulatory intervention, stating "Fundamentally, it's appalling that a group of faceless, anonymous people on the other side of Australia get involved in free enterprise here" [1]. The city, located approximately 600km east of Perth with a population of 30,000, currently has six supermarkets including an existing Coles in the CBD [1].
The ACCC's decision cited concerns about potential harm to smaller independent competitors, particularly O'Connor Fresh IGA, located about 2km from the proposed development [1]. ACCC lawyer Declan Roche SC argued that Coles expansion would represent a "substantial lessening of competition" and noted that O'Connor Fresh IGA flagged a "commercially real possibility" it would exit the market [1]. The watchdog assessed that competition would be significantly impacted if the independent operator closed, given its unregulated operating hours that benefit local shift workers [1]. Coles, which operates 860 supermarkets nationwide, characterized the ACCC decision as having a "chilling effect" on investment [1].
CONCLUSION
The Coles appeal represents a pivotal test case for Australia's strengthened merger laws, with the Competition Tribunal's decision expected within 90 days potentially setting precedent for future retail expansion decisions [1]. The case highlights tension between regulatory protection of local competition and corporate investment expansion, with significant implications for how the ACCC applies its new powers in regional markets [1].