The VanEck Agribusiness ETF (MOO) and iShares MSCI Agriculture Producers ETF (VEGI) have significantly outperformed the broader market over the past year, with MOO returning approximately 18% and VEGI returning approximately 15% from November 17, 2025, through November 18, 2026, with distributions reinvested, compared to 11% for the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV) [1]. However, this recent outperformance masks a concerning long-term trend: over five years starting November 18, 2021, MOO lost about 5% while VEGI gained 17%, both significantly trailing the S&P 500's 67% gain [1].
Both ETFs track the same agricultural supply chain but with notably different weightings, creating distinct risk profiles [1]. MOO, which tracks the MVIS Global Agribusiness Index with 50 holdings, offers broader diversification across the food production ecosystem, including positions in Bayer (approximately 9%), Corteva (approximately 9%), Deere (approximately 9%), Nutrien (approximately 6%), Archer-Daniels-Midland (approximately 5%), and Zoetis (approximately 5%) [1]. In contrast, VEGI shows significant concentration risk, with Deere comprising 28% of the fund compared to only 9% in MOO, making VEGI's performance heavily dependent on a single equipment manufacturer [1].
The funds' holdings span the entire agricultural value chain from seeds and crop protection through fertilizers, grain processing, livestock health, and farm equipment [1]. Key positions include Corteva (approximately 9-10% across both funds), Bunge (approximately 3% of each), CF Industries (approximately 4% of each), and Kubota (approximately 5% in MOO and 3% in VEGI) [1]. While MOO's diversification across 50 positions provides exposure to multiple segments of the agricultural supply chain, the article notes that Bayer's Roundup litigation and MOO's single annual payout structure present potential headwinds [1].
CONCLUSION
While MOO and VEGI have delivered strong one-year returns exceeding the S&P 500, their significant five-year underperformance suggests recent gains may reflect cyclical strength rather than structural outperformance. VEGI's heavy concentration in Deere (28% of holdings) presents elevated single-stock risk compared to MOO's more diversified 50-position approach, making fund selection critical for agricultural exposure.